Our concern is with misinterpreting the graphical presentation of. Is stereotype threat overcooked, overstated, and oversold. Article information, pdf download for when beliefs yield to evidence. Sackett et al see record 200410043001 have raised a concern. The challenges of stereotype threat for the testing community. Stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance of african. Converging evidence that stereotype threat reduces. We investigated performance implications for the stereotype of poor driving ability in older. Pdf stereotype threat and the intellectual testperformance of. Journal of personality and social psychology, 695, 797811.
In 1995 claude steele and joshua aronson tested is hypo issis that is differences in performance on iq tests between blacks and whites might be due. In 1995 claude steele and joshua aronson tested is hypo issis that is differences in performance on iq tests between blacks and. For example, blascovich, spencer, quinn, and steele 2001 reported that african ameri. Aronson 1995 showed that making race salient when taking a difficult test affected the performance of highability african american students, a phenomenon they termed stereotype threat. Steele and aronson gave black and white college students a halfhour test using difficult items from the verbal graduate record exam gre. The authors attributed this performance decrement to the evaluation pressures created by the possibility of confirming the negative stereotype that african americans lack academic ability. Here the data show that when the negative stereotype of black intellectual ability is made salient for example, by characterizing the test as diagnostic vs. Studies 1 and 2 varied the stereotype vulnerability of black participants taking a difficult verbal test by varying whether or not their performance was ostensibly diagnostic of ability.
The effects of stereotype in the classroom are striking. In the stereotypethreat condition, they told students the test diagnosed intellectual ability, thus potentially eliciting the. Pdf stereotype threat does not live by steele and aronson. Research has shown that stereotype threat can harm the academic performance of any individual for whom the situaon invokes a stereotypebased. In our work, we focus on the insiders view, asking what is the experience of being african american for black youths. This experiment involved the participation of african american and white college students. Steele and aronson s 1995 stereotype threat was applied in a vein inspired by deaux et al.
To be more specific, it is a situationinduced threat that applies others stereotypes to oneself, which will later have a negative impact on ones performance related to. Research has shown that stereotype threat can harm the academic performance of any individual for whom the situaon invokes a. Thus, men, as a high status group, should show stereotype threat when they are presented with the negative stereotype that men are not as socially sensitive as women, an ability ordinarily operationalized as the ability to decode others nonverbal cues. Convey that diversity is valued for instance, communicate a multicultural ideology that explicitly values diversity purdievaughns et al. Other research revealed that stereotype threat effects emerged most strongly on tests that are believed to be diagnostic of ability in the stereotyped domain e. The influence of stereotype threat on the responses of black.
David sparks explains, some students have a fear of confirming a stereotype for a group to which they belong e. Journal of personality abd social psychology, 69, 797811. Stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance of. They know at some level, that they are in a predicament. Method previous sat scores were taken from participants before the experiment began. Pdf on interpreting stereotype threat as accounting for. The challenges of stereotype threat for the testing community ets. The term, stereotype threat, was first used by steele and aronson 1995 who showed in several experiments that black college freshmen and sophomores performed more poorly on standardized tests than white students when their race was emphasized. On interpreting stereotype threat as accounting for african american. A white experimenter said they would be working on verbal problems identical to a sat exam 25 minutes. Test difficulty and stereotype threat on the greb general test. Stereotype threat stereotype threat is a form of social identity threat that individuals experience when they may be judged negatively based on a situationally relevant group stereotype spencer et al. Stereotype threat and intellectual test performance of african americans.
Aronson, journaljournal of personality and social psychology, year 1995, volume69 5, pages 797811. Steele and aronson 1995 suggest that black consumers protect themselves from stereotypical black media images by distinguishing and classifying various. In 1995, claude steele and joshua aronson performed the first experiments demonstrating that stereotype threat can undermine intellectual performance. Stereotype threat and inflexible perseverance in problem solving. Stereotype threat and the nature and nurture of intelligence. Spencer, steele, and quinn 1999, although this increase in performance has generally not been ascribed to. To elicit stereotype threat, there may be no need to either directly present people with the stereotype spencer et al. African american identity in adolescence usc dornsife. Blacks and whites verbal gre performance laboratory experiment on stereotype threat. Stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance of african americans. Apprehension arising from the awareness of a negative stereotype or personal reputation in a situation where the stereotype or identity is. Study 3 was designed to test the hypothesis that shifting participants evaluative frameworks could reduce the experience of stereotype threat. In steele and aronson s 1995 seminal article stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance of african americans the authors presented four studies to establish the theory of st by testing the negative academic effects of the negative stereotype that african americans have poor verbal ability.
Stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance of african american. Journa l o f personalit y an d socia l psychology, 1995, vol. Stereotype threat and race of interviewer effects in a survey. There has since been an explosion of related research, much of which has applied the concept of. In this study, steele and aronson observed the performance of black and white students on academic tests. Empirically validated strategies to reduce stereotype threat. They reasoned that knowledge of the prevalent cultural stereotype asserting. Aim determine the effect of stereotype threat on performance participants 20 female african american stanford participants and 20 caucasian stanford female undergraduates. In what became a landmark study, black and white participants took a scholatic aptitude test, which was framed as either diagnostic of intellectual ability or as nonindicative of ability. The present research examined the role these processes play. Pdf stereotype threat and the intellectual testperformance. Stereotype threat, mental arithmetic, and the mere effort.
Introduction to islamic culture the concept of islamic culture the relationship of culture to science and. This situational pressure can be sufficient to interfere in the normal cognitive functioning of the individual and to impair hisher performance. N t i th a d i i t llinurturing the academic intelligence of. In the first study published on stereotype threat, steele and aronson 1995, study 1 investigated the performance on an ability test graduate. It was hypothesized that giving participants learning goals would attenuate the negative consequences of ste. Steele and aronson s 1995 effort focused on the immediate situational threat that derives from the broad dissemination on ones groupthe threat of possibly being judged and treated stereotypically, or of possibly selffulfilling such a stereotype p. Stereotype threat was manipulated by telling one group that. Attitudes and social cognition stereotype threat and. Studies have shown that anyone has the potential to fall prey to stereotype threat, even members of otherwise privileged groups.
Stereotype threat, mental arithmetic, and the mere effort account. In a different application of stereotype threat, et al. The research on interviewer effects in surveys has produced compelling evidence of how seriously the pro. Steele and aronson 2004 take issue with our comparison of african american white differences on the prior sat and on grebased scores in the two.
Measures of political and social attitudes will tend to reflect more than expressed opinions but also come to reflect an attempt to project a positive selfimage. Given the prevalence of stereotype threat in traditional testing situations, researchers most. The authors document that this research is widely misinterpreted in both popular and scholarly publications as showing that eliminating stereotype threat eliminates the african american. Journal of personality and social psychology, 695, 797811, are less able to abandon old strategies and employ newer, more ef. Studies 1 and 2 varied the stereotype vulnerability of black participants taking a difficult verbal test by varying whether or not their performance was ostensibly diagnostic of ability, and thus, whether or not they were at risk of fulfilling the racial stereotype about their. No child left behind, stereotype threat, and the standardized. Although selfreported measures of anxiety show mixed results, there is some evidence to suggest that stereotype threat involves heightened levels of anxiety and arousal. A large literature has emerged showing that when college students from stigmatized minority groups are made aware of negative societal stereotypes about their group, a decline in academic performance is observed. Aronson 1995 showed that making race salient when taking a difficult test affected the performance of highability african american students, a phenomenon they termed. Diagnostic condition interaction in steele and aronson 1995. The counseling psychologist contending with the authors. They completed an important early study in 1995 which defined stereotype threat as being at risk of confirming, as selfcharacteristic, a negative stereotype about ones group. Stereotype threat theory assumes that underperformance is triggered by the possibility of being judged in terms of said stereotype.
Converging evidence that stereotype threat reduces working. Theoretically, stereotype threat can happen to anyone with a group identity laden with. Steele, department of psychology, stanford university, stanford, california 94305, or joshua aronson, school of education, university of texas, austin, texas 78712. Steele and aronson 1995 the experiment the aim of the experiment was to test if african americans showed an example of the stereotype threat. In the stereotypethreat condition, they told students the test diagnosed intellectual ability, thus potentially eliciting the stereotype that blacks are less intelligent than whites. Stereotype threat has been shown to negatively impact the performance of stigmatized individuals in a variety of domains.
Steele, departmen t o f psychology, stanfor d university, stan ford, californi a 94305, o r joshu a aronson, schoo l o f education, uni versit y o f texas, austin, texa s 78712. Aronson 1995 showed that making race salient when taking a difficult test affected the performance of highability african american. For example, the stereotype threat that women experience in mathrelated domains may cause them to feel that they do not belong in math classes. The influence of stereotype threat on the responses of. Stereotype threat steele, aronson learning theories. Steele and aronson 1995 found that making race salient before a test or describing a test as diagnostic of ability led african american students to perform significantly worse than both their white counterparts and other african american students not told the test was diagnostic of ability. Stereotype threat is being at risk of confirming, as selfcharacteristic, a negative stereotype about ones group. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Stereotype threat in men on a test of social sensitivity. When negative stereotypes about the intelligence of blacks are highlighted, black students perform worse. Pdf stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance.
Our premise is that in urban centers black youths cannot choose to. Their performance could confirm a bad view of their group and of themselves, as members of that group p. The role of performanceavoidance goals and worry in. Attitudes and social cognition stereotype threat and the.
1356 1305 365 219 1059 268 1243 1016 626 620 1310 1479 636 790 751 1362 123 1334 390 481 67 7 749 740 600 627 1118